Socialists be very, very warned.
It's no secret that I have a very low opinion of the public school system. There are several reasons for this, most, if not all, of which I didn't even begin to think about until I was around fifteen. My decision to homeschool came quite soon afterwards. Obviously, it was an incredibly difficult choice to make. Just a year and a half earlier, I'd made a very similar decision when finding a high school in the first place. My base school was very near to my house, and all of my friends were going to go there. At first, my mom wanted me to go to the school where my sister was (ironically, where I ended up going), but I'd refused because I wanted to stay with my friends. However, I kept thinking about it all, and figured out that I really wanted to learn Japanese, which was offered at the school where my sister went, but not my base school. I'm not sure whether that was the sole reason for my decision at that point, or whether other factors eventually came into play, but it's the only one I can coherently recall.
So I ended up going to a rather inner-city school where I began with exactly zero friends. Looking back, I wasn't very wise--even just four years ago. However, I quickly made friends with many of the other people who were taking Japanese. Some may consider them to be of the goth/punk/emo variety, but they were really rather fun and energetic--perhaps more accurately described as the anime type (if there even is a particular "anime type"). For my entire freshman year and half of my sophmore year, I grew closer to this very large group of people at my school and got to know many of the members (which, for someone as relatively anti-social as I, is a fairly large feat). Thus, one might understand that I was really freaking upset when I left.
Nevertheless, I still believe that I made the correct decision for my education--partly because I truly feel justified in that, and partly probably simply because I sort of have to so that I didn't leave all my friends (twice) for nothing. Most predominant is probably the fact that public education sucks. Nothing against the teachers, or even most of the administrators and students, but more the entire concept. And even that statement covers a lot of ground.
To begin, I despise the curricula (heck, maybe even the
idea of a curriculum). Children and teenagers are far too impressionable for what they learn to ever be decided by the government. Granted, many parents manage to teach their children basic intelligence outside the system, but still far too many neglect this duty, such that they grow up learning only what the state wants them to learn. I really shouldn't need to explain how or why this is an absolutely terrible situation, but just in case, here's what Hitler had to say on the subject: "When an opponent declares, 'I will not come over to your side,' I calmly say, 'Your child belongs to us already... What are you? You will pass on. Your descendants, however, now stand in the new camp. In a short time they will know nothing else but this new community.'" And Lenin stated, "Give me four years to teach the children and the seed I have sown will never be uprooted." And hey, let's throw in a little Stalin for good measure: "Education is a weapon, whose effect depends on who holds it in his hands and at whom it is aimed." Evil or not (and they were) those guys did tell the truth about a good many things, present topic most assuredly included. Education is an extremely powerful tool that shapes the minds of every single person for the rest of their lives, and it is my opinion that any one body should ever be responsible for all of them. If that happens, the governing body will quickly figure out how easily they can engrain into young minds the idea that they (the people) need the aforementioned body to have more power.
...And that's only problem number one.
Second, the teachers and administrators get what I like to call "DMV syndrome," which has more to do with economics than anything else. Granted, that's not to say that they don't care about their students' education--far from it, otherwise they wouldn't have gotten into teaching in the first place. They simply don't work as hard as they might if, say, they wouldn't have the unions raising hell over a firing for anything short of molestation. Heck, we even just learned about this in psychology class on monday! Perhaps not this specific example, but the general theme. Simply put, they're getting paid to teach, so they teach--positive reinforcement--but they lack the negtive reinforcement of "If these kids come out of this class completely ignorant of ___
subject___, you'll be fired so we can hire someone who knows what they're doing." Therefore, the teachers eventually become apathetic towards their students' individual success in the class.
Thomas Sowell taught me well in my first semester at home. This is probably the biggest factor in my homeschooling, even though I didn't know it at the time. As I put it, I was "sick of not learning." Recently, however, I've realized that my style of learning is somewhat more autodidactic than most (and infinitely more so than all the "teamwork" scheiß they were trying to shove down my throat) to begin with, so it's not entirely the school system's fault in that case.
Then, of course, there was the constant barrage of feel-good talking points about diversity and
achievement and all that (Yeah, the link is just a little comic relief). No, that wasn't even really the problem. It's more like they're trying to force everyone to shove themselves into the academic world, and completely forgo any other possible profession--especially since we aren't "allowed" to drop out of school before the age of 16, and even then can't get a driver's license until 18 if we do so. I suppose it's not that surprising, though, considering how absolutely cheap everything is now here. We get all our trade from China and hard work from illegals, and all (or at least the very large majority) of our products are made from oil (plastic, yadda, yadda, yadda...), so we don't really have as much of a need for all the trade/merchant/artisan jobs that were so necessary in the past. Carpenters, blacksmiths, glassmakers, masons, farm hands, mechanics, etc. Those careers are all but obsolete save for making souvenirs from small towns. This leaves a terrible predicament for young people who aren't naturally inclined to be good at math or science or humanities. I have a friend who is living with this exact problem and now works part-time at a pretzel place and spends the rest of his time playing World of Warcraft in his parents' basement. His parents won't pay for him to go to college, but from what I've heard, he doesn't seem to like the idea of more school very much. He has no direction in his life, and claimed to not enjoy anything but WoW and hanging out with friends. I knew that he really enjoys working on cars, so I suggested that he be a mechanic. This was met with a "yeah, maybe." The problem is that this is becoming increasingly common nowadays. This generation has taken on the mindset that if we don't go to college, we can't make anything of our lives. A century ago (and beyond), my friend would likely have been sent to be an apprentice at a young age, so that he could learn a trade that would be useful to society and earn him a good income for the rest of his life. But no... no college, no future: that's what we're taught.
I believe those are the three most important issues in the public school system that concern me. This took five hours to write; you can't say that I don't have a lot of thoughts.
UPDATE: Blast! I forgot to include the whole "dragging the better students down so the others' feelings aren't hurt" thing. Here's an example, though: There are sometimes three levels of each course for high school. In order from hardest to easiest, they are: AP (advanced placement), Honors, and Academic (regular...ish). My sister was once put in an AP course for one of these, and the school decided to mix the academic level and AP level classes together, supposedly to help push the academic students harder and to make them do better. Obviously, this didn't work one bit. The AP students were all doing horribly and got PO'd because it was now moving far too slow for them to actually be able to get anything done. That's fair, for you.