Joss Whedon, you wonderful, crazy, maniacal genius, you've done it again.
Overall Impression: Words cannot possibly express just how great this was (and still is for another 12 hours or so).
Oh, where to begin with the praises? I hadn't known that this existed until the very day the first part came out, but I am eternally grateful that it came to my attention in time. The characters were perfectly portrayed, the songs kicked the butts of the ones in the
musical Buffy episode (or really any musical ever made. And yes, that includes
Sondheim's works--and I
love Sweeney Todd), and the story was just too ingenius for this universe.
First, I suppose, shall be the characters. They were slightly cliche--the nerdy guy/supervillain who can't talk to a girl, the egocentric superhero who sort of bullies him, the ultra-caring girl herself, the Evil league of Evil, etc.--but there was one important thing that helped that fact make it better than anything else with a combination even vaguely similar to that: it wasn't overdone. The dialogue was simple and casual, the scenes weren't more dramatic than need be, and most importantly, the acting wasn't extreme in any way (with the possible exception of Captain Hammer, but he may have needed the extra boost of narcissism to lend more sympathy to Dr. Horrible). There were no exaggerated movements, no yelling where it's unnecessary, no dramatic pitch changes, nothing of the sort. That just seems to be a very common thing to do in spoofs of any sort--especially of the superhero genre--and everything really works better in the absence of that.
The songs--a necessary part of any musical--were very beautiful. Perhaps it's just preference of characters or certain themes, but I tended not to enjoy the pieces sung by Penny very much. I did, however, love the large majority of them. From the Bad Horse songs to the... uhh... 2nd to last one where he's all creepy and stuff (I don't know the name of it!). Apparently, Neil Patrick Harris sings
incredibly well.
Now for the story itself, and--oh my goodness--I loved it so very much. As someone with a minor obsession with unusual hero/villain positions in plot (whether by changing who is the protagonist and/or changing whether the protagonist prevails in the end), I found it to be just about perfect, and certainly couldn't have done any better in my various attempts at writing. So now I'm jealous. Thanks, Joss.
But really (WARNING: Spoilers ahead), it couldn't have been any more awesome. Dr. Horrible has the two main goals: get into the Evil League of Evil, and get Penny to like him. Throughout the acts, Penny starts dating Captain Hammer after they meet basically due to a mishap or two during Dr. Horrible's wonderflonium heist. For this reason, along with the fact that Bad Horse demands a killing, he decides to kill Captain Hammer.
This is where it gets interesting and ultra-spoileriffic. There are a few possible endings when the villain is the protagonist, and only the stupidest one can really be considered happy. The protagonist can win and acheive his goal, which is sure to cause people suffering. Alternatively, he could lose and, while people will be saved, the person with whom the audience has connected and sympathized ultimately fails. This means he either dies, goes to jail, has various other misfortune befall him, or (the stupid ending here) is somehow convinced to become good. That being said, Joss Whedon and his totally unfair amount of awesome came up with something completely unexpected that I couldn't forsee. His plan to kill Captain Hammer fails, at which point the death ray explodes and Captain Hammer is defeated while Penny is killed by the shrapnel from the gun. Her death, however, gets Dr. Horrible exactly what he wanted: fear and power amongst the general population and a position in the Evil League of Evil. So it's a bit of a bitter-bitter-bittersweet ending. He gets what he wanted, but at a terrible price (TANSTAAFL to the extreme).
All things considered, it was the best thing to hit the internet since Al Gore invented it. I don't know about everyone else, but I plan to watch it as many times as possible before I'd have to pay for it. Who knows, though? Perhaps I'll get the DVD when that comes out. Later, guys.